Wedding MusicLetter

Wedding MusicLetter

Share this post

Wedding MusicLetter
Wedding MusicLetter
🎵 20 Alternatives to the Wedding Cake-Cutting

🎵 20 Alternatives to the Wedding Cake-Cutting

Spice up your reception with unique & delicious alternatives to the traditional wedding cake-cutting ceremony.

Matthew Campbell's avatar
Matthew Campbell
Jul 02, 2025
∙ Paid
2

Share this post

Wedding MusicLetter
Wedding MusicLetter
🎵 20 Alternatives to the Wedding Cake-Cutting
Share

Read Article Online

Cue “Cut the Cake” by Average White Band! (record scratch)

I believe every tradition deserves a new take, and the wedding cake-cutting ceremony is no exception.

Whether you're not a cake couple, want a more interactive moment, or just looking to surprise your guests with something unexpected (and delicious), these music-paired alternatives hit all the right notes (pun intended).

From pizza slices to pancake flips, each idea brings its own flavor and a soundtrack to match.

20 Alternatives to the Wedding Cake Cutting

1. Donut Wall “First Pull”

Let the couple pull donuts off a decked-out wall.

Music Pairing: “Sugar” by Maroon 5 - upbeat, fun, and totally sweet. “Donuts, Donuts, Donuts” by LZ - funny.

2. Signature Sip Toast

The couple mixes and shares their own signature cocktails or mocktails.

Music Pairing: “Cheers (Drink to That)” by Rihanna - a party-starting toast anthem. "Raise Your Glass" by P!nk - another themed toast hype song.

3. Candy Bar Love Swap

Exchange your favorite candy bars in a cute, nostalgic twist. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup for me!

Music Pairing: “I Want Candy” by Bow Wow Wow - playful and cheeky. “Candy” by Cameo - for a more risque but themed song.

4. Mini Bundt Cake Tower

Cut personal bundts, each with a unique flavor. Each guest can select their own flavor too. Nothing Bundt Cakes is the perfect supplier of these desserts.

Music Pairing: “Sweetest Thing” by U2 - romantic and heartfelt. “Cake by the Ocean” by DNCE for a more upbeat selection.

5. Ice Cream Unity Scoop

Share scoops from a vintage cart or artisan vendor. It can even be gelato. Think Ben & Jerry's to Baskin-Robbins.

Music Pairing: “Ice Cream” by BLACKPINK & Selena Gomez - flirty and fun. “Ice Cream” by Sarah McLachlan - romantic touch.

6. Taco Bar Toast

They build tacos for each other and share a bite. Your wedding does not have to be on a Tuesday to make this happen!

Music Pairing: “Taco Grande” by “Weird Al” Yankovic - lighthearted and hilarious. “Raining Tacos” by Parry Gripp - another funny but hype song.

7. Pizza Slice Ceremony

Half-and-half pizza, pulled apart for the perfect photo op. It’s even okay for those who like pineapple on their pizza LOL.

Music Pairing: “That’s Amore” by Dean Martin - classic, kitschy, crowd-pleasing, and fits the Italian pizza vibe. “Pizza” by Martin Garrix - An EDM instrumental anthem.

8. Coffee Pour-Over Unity

Brew and sip their favorite roast together. Be sure to include their favorite sugar and creamers too - just the way they like it.

Music Pairing: “The Coffee Song” by Frank Sinatra - smooth and jazzy. “Falling In Love At A Coffee Shop” by Landon Pigg - indie romantic vibe.

9. S’mores Campfire Exchange

Roast, stack, and share the gooey goodness.

Music Pairing: “Set Fire to the Rain” by Adele - a theme of setting a fire. “Campfire” by Satellite Stories - upbeat indie rock track.

10. Popcorn Flavor Toss

Trade custom popcorn mixes (think cheddar caramel, matcha, truffle).

Music Pairing: “Popcorn” by Hot Butter - retro, quirky instrumental. “Popcorn” by Barenaked Ladies - another quirky offbeat pop-rock song.

11. Bubble Tea Cheers

Sip matching or mixed bubble teas with colorful straws.

Music Pairing: “Bubble Pop!” by HyunA - energetic and K-pop fabulous. “Bubble Tea” by sonyo - an indie rock with a perfect smooth vibe.

12. Pancake Stack Flip

Cook or stack mini pancakes, add toppings, and feed each other.

Music Pairing: “Banana Pancakes” by Jack Johnson - chill and romantic. “Pancakes & Butter” by Jason Mraz - a romantic pop track.

13. Cheesecake Dip Platter

Dip into bite-sized cheesecake cubes with sauces and toppings. Think fondue love!

Music Pairing: “How Sweet It Is (To Be Loved by You)” by Marvin Gaye -or- James Taylor - smooth and timeless. “Cheesecake” by Louis Armstrong - a fun and classic jazz tune.

14. Chocolate Fountain First Dip

Dip marshmallows, fruit, or even pretzels. Whatever suits your fancy, as they say.

Music Pairing: “Chocolate” by The 1975 - mellow with a hint of groove. “Chocolate” by Snow Patrol - Alternative rock with a heartfelt tone.

15. Crepe Suzette Fire Show

Flambéed crepes or desserts prepared live.

Music Pairing: “Burn” by Ellie Goulding - dramatic and dazzling. “Fire” by The Pointer Sisters - a flirty R&B classic.

16. Pie Cutting & Sharing

Rustic pies (think bourbon pecan, strawberry rhubarb). You can even keep it simple with apple and cherry.

Music Pairing: “American Pie” by Don McLean - nostalgic and storytelling-rich. “Cherry Pie” by Warrant - classic rock hits the spot.

17. Cookie Dunk Off

A milk and cookies exchange. You can even have a dunking challenge.

Music Pairing: “Milkshake” by Kelis - cheeky and dance-worthy. “Cookie Jar” by Gym Class Heroes - a pop-rap hit.

18. Froyo Topping Ritual

Serve frozen yogurt with sweet toppings.

Music Pairing: “Cold as Ice” by Foreigner - a rock anthem with a biting message. “Let It Go” by Idina Menzel (from Frozen) - the ultimate cold-weather anthem.

19. Fruit Skewer Toast

Juicy, colorful fruit skewers are arranged and exchanged.

Music Pairing: “Peaches” by Justin Bieber - summery and mellow. “Strawberry Fields Forever” by The Beatles - a classic inspired by a real place.

20. Macaron Tower Moment

Choose a colored macaron and feed each other from a dazzling tower.

Music Pairing: “La Vie en Rose” by Édith Piaf - sweet, chic, and très romantique. “Je te Laisserai des Mots” by Patrick Watson - tender and poetic.

Do you have an idea to add to the list? Please share in an email reply.

Paid subscribers have access to the Spotify Playlist below!

Thanks for reading!

Matthew Campbell

Wedding MusicLetter

P.S. Check out my wedding music planning bookstore for printed books and digital downloads.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 My Wedding Songs
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share